Third-Party Diminished Value Claims: The Secret Insurance Won't Tell You
- C. Smith
- Aug 26
- 3 min read
As someone who has spent more than 25 years in the automotive industry, I can tell you this: a repaired car is never quite the same in the marketplace. Even if the body shop does a flawless job, once your car has been in an accident, it carries a record, and that record lowers its value.
This drop in resale value is what we call diminished value. And in Virginia, if the accident wasn’t your fault, you may have the right to recover that loss through a third-party diminished value claim.
What Exactly Is a Third-Party Diminished Value Claim?
Simply put, it’s your request for fair compensation from the at-fault driver’s insurance company. Their policy may pay to repair your car, but repairs don’t erase the fact that your vehicle now has an accident history. When you go to sell or trade it in, dealers and private buyers will factor that in, and they’ll pay you less.
A diminished value claim is designed to bridge that gap, so you aren’t the one absorbing the financial loss.
How the Process Works
Accident Happens – Your car is damaged by another driver.
Repairs Are Made – Their insurance covers the cost of fixing your vehicle.
You File for Diminished Value – You submit evidence that your car is worth less than it was before the accident.
That evidence usually comes in the form of a professional market analysis, repair documents, and a written demand to the insurer.
Why Many Drivers Miss Out
Insurance companies rarely volunteer this information. They’ll repair your car, but unless you know to ask for diminished value, and can prove it, they’re more than happy to let you absorb the hidden loss.
Most vehicle owners don’t realize they have this right. And even those who do often struggle to show the numbers in a way the insurance company will take seriously.
How The Car Mentor Can Help
This is where we step in as your automotive expert. Our role is to stand in your corner and give you the tools to level the playing field.
Here’s what we do at The Car Mentor:
Independent Value Assessment – We calculate your car’s worth before and after the accident.
Professional Claim Package – We prepare the documentation that insurance adjusters need to see.
Guidance Through the Process – We walk you step by step so you know exactly what to submit and how to follow up.
Advocacy That Saves You Time and Stress – Instead of fighting a frustrating battle with an insurance company on your own, you have an experienced automotive professional by your side.
With the right data and approach, many drivers are able to recover hundreds or even thousands of dollars that would otherwise be lost forever.
Final Word
You’ve invested in your vehicle, don’t let an accident take away more than it already has. Repairs restore your car’s function, but a diminished value claim restores its financial worth.
At The Car Mentor, we don’t just guide you through the process, we fight for the value your car deserves.
Call us today at 804-210-5474 or Visit: thecarmentor.net.
Watch our breakdown here: https://youtu.be/BjvfpOr7UN8
Because when it comes to your car, you deserve more than repairs, you deserve fairness.
Comments